Monticello, NY - On January 16th, 2024, Timothy Finnegan pled guilty to one count of Criminal Possession of a Narcotic Drug in the 4th Degree for the possession of cocaine.
This conviction followed an undercover investigation by the New York State Police in the Town of Mamakating, whereby the Sullivan County District Attorney’s Office assisted in obtaining a search warrant of a residence for illegal firearms and narcotics. As a result of executing the search warrant, members of the New York State Police recovered approximately sixteen grams of cocaine as well as two illegal firearms, including a pistol and a revolver. The defendant and two other individuals were charged in connection with the bust.
Following the defendant’s plea of guilty, he failed to appear for his scheduled sentencing on March 18th, 2024. The Honorable James R. Farrell issued a bench warrant to secure his appearance for sentence. On or about May 26th, 2026, nearly two years later, the defendant was located by law enforcement, arrested, returned on the bench warrant, and remanded pending his sentence.
Due to the defendant’s failure to appear at sentencing, the People requested that the court enhance the defendants originally agreed-upon sentence. At sentencing, Chief Assistant District Attorney, Michael Puma, requested that the court sentence the defendant to six years in state prison followed by three years of post-release supervision. The defense attorney, Elissa Killian, Esq., opposed this application. Ultimately, the court agreed to sentence the defendant consistent with the People’s recommendation.
District Attorney Brian P. Conaty stated, “I want to thank the New York State Police for their detailed undercover investigative efforts that led to a search warrant and the removal of dangerous guns and drugs from the streets of Sullivan County. Those who otherwise lead a law abiding and productive life and suffer from addiction will receive help, those who use their addiction to further criminal activity will continue to be held accountable.”
